
Commercial Property and Casualty Producer
Gibbel Insurance Agency
Commercial Insurance Producer
Gibbel Insurance Agency, Inc. | Lititz, PA
Expected Annual Compensation: $50,000–$85,000 (Base Salary + Commission)
Build Relationships. Grow Your Book. Build Your Career.
Are you a motivated sales professional who enjoys meeting people, building relationships, and helping businesses succeed? Are you looking for an opportunity where you can take ownership of your success while being supported by an experienced, collaborative team?
Gibbel Insurance Agency is growing, and we're looking for the right person to grow with us.
Founded in 1890, Gibbel Insurance is a fourth-generation, family-owned independent insurance agency serving Lancaster County and surrounding communities. We've built our reputation on personal relationships, trusted advice, exceptional service, and doing what's right for our clients.
As our commercial insurance opportunities continue to increase, we're looking for a personable, driven Commercial Insurance Producer to help us develop those opportunities and build a successful, long-term book of business.
You won't be starting from scratch.
We have an established client base, strong community relationships, experienced insurance professionals, and a growing number of commercial opportunities ready for someone to develop. You'll work closely with agency leadership and our service team while building your own network of clients and referral relationships.
What You'll Do
- Develop new commercial insurance business through agency-generated opportunities, referrals, networking, and proactive prospecting.
- Build meaningful relationships with business owners and decision-makers throughout Lancaster County and surrounding communities.
- Meet with prospective clients to understand their businesses, identify exposures, and recommend appropriate insurance solutions.
- Cultivate opportunities within our existing personal lines client base.
- Build and manage a book of commercial insurance business, focusing on long-term relationships, retention, and growth.
- Work closely with our commercial account managers and insurance carrier partners to develop competitive insurance proposals.
- Maintain an organized sales pipeline, track activities, and consistently follow up with prospects.
- Represent Gibbel Insurance professionally through community involvement, networking, and relationship-building.
What We're Looking For
We're looking for someone with a strong sales foundation, a genuine interest in people, and the motivation to build something meaningful.
Our ideal candidate has:
- 3–5 years of successful sales, business development, or relationship-management experience preferred.
- Property & Casualty insurance experience preferred, particularly in commercial lines, but not required.
- An outgoing, approachable personality and the confidence to connect with business owners.
- Strong communication, listening, and consultative selling skills.
- A self-motivated, entrepreneurial mindset with the initiative to develop new opportunities.
- Excellent organization, follow-through, and time-management skills.
- A collaborative attitude and appreciation for working as part of a team.
- Comfort using technology, CRM systems, and digital sales tools.
- An active Pennsylvania Property & Casualty insurance license preferred, or willingness to obtain one.
Most importantly, we're looking for the right person: someone who enjoys people, takes initiative, follows through on commitments, and wants to develop a rewarding career in commercial insurance.
Why Join Gibbel Insurance?
An Established Agency with a Strong Reputation
With more than 135 years of history, we're proud of the relationships we've built and the trust we've earned in our community. You'll benefit from an established name, a broad client base, and strong carrier relationships.
Opportunities Ready to Develop
We're experiencing increased commercial insurance opportunities and want to invest in someone who can help us capitalize on that growth. You'll have access to existing prospects, referrals, and cross-selling opportunities while developing your own book of business.
Support Without Micromanagement
You'll work directly with experienced agency leadership and a knowledgeable team that wants you to succeed. We provide support, collaboration, and the freedom to take ownership of your work.
A Culture Where People Matter
We're a family-owned agency that values integrity, teamwork, flexibility, community involvement, and work-life balance. We believe in treating our employees and clients with respect and building relationships that last.
A Career with Growth Potential
This is an opportunity to build a long-term career, develop your professional skills, grow your income, and become an important part of our agency's future.
Compensation & Benefits
- Expected annual total compensation of $50,000–$85,000, including base salary and commissions, depending on experience and production.
- Base salary providing financial stability while developing a book of business.
- Performance-based commission opportunities that reward new business production.
- Support from experienced agency leadership and commercial insurance professionals.
- Professional development and ongoing insurance industry training.
- A collaborative, flexible, family-oriented work environment.
Interested? Let's Talk!
If you're a relationship-driven sales professional who enjoys helping people and wants an opportunity to grow, we'd love to hear from you.
Whether you're already working in commercial insurance or are a successful salesperson interested in entering the industry, we encourage you to apply.
Gibbel Insurance Agency, Inc.
Lititz, Pennsylvania
Building relationships that last since 1890.
Pay: $50,000.00 - $85,000.00 per year
Benefits:
- 401(k) matching
- Dental insurance
- Health insurance
- Paid time off
- Vision insurance
- Work from home
Work Location: Hybrid remote in Lititz, PA 17543
Job details
- Location
- Lititz, PA
- Job category
- Insurance Production
- Insurance line
- Commercial Property and Casualty
- Employment type
- Full-time
- Experience level
- Experienced
- Required credentials
- Property and Casualty License
- Posted
- Oct 30, 2026
